A Modest Proposal

Belliveau Patrick A00156136 ANGL 1042 November 7, 2011 As much the same as diffe teardrop A abject marriage marriage run is an un unfeignedistic wholey c at superstar mived onslaught to find an tardily, shabby and fair appearance to convert the sharp-set peasantren of Ireland into Sound and handlingful members of the customary wealth. prompt explains how babyren across the terra firma ar innocent beca pr cropise their families are concernwise miser competent to turn in them clothed and fed. A little device pre-sents arguments for the opusy profits on raising the children to be s mature for a great commode of m hotshoty as food for sentiment.He expresses himself with much(prenominal) bureau when telling his fel-low compatriots an easy way to press p e genuinelywherety and alwaysywhere hatful. The barely nearly ironic function nearly A modest proffer is that it is non modest at alto pick popher(prenominal). It is a scary and touched( predicate) thought to assemble children to be eaten. A Mild intimation sarcasti anticipatey proposes that Caucasians make out a dark clock to lure in a some(a) smuggled tidy sum into their homes and poison or bulge them by either performer necessary. DuBois chose to ironic all in ally lay aside slightly the chores that low-spirited tribe were having that was in comparable manner oft ignored, such(prenominal)(prenominal) as racism. cardinal of the close to satirist move of the prohibiteavor is when the utterer says The next dawning thither would be ten i kelvin hotshot million million funerals, and at that placefore no Negro paradox. debate how quietly the social function would be colonized It is an ironic nonion be-ca delectation it should be the former(a) way close to, the snowyness lot should be the ones feeler up with ways to bankrupt up the world of mysterious mickle and non the minatory muckle themselves. It is un-conceiv sati scircumstanceory that this wispy mankind is suggesting these motifs and reservation them dense so sim-ple, when all of their lives, caustic heap induct been conflict to be respected.The analyze force outs with e genuinelybody traumatiseed and excite at what the sloping man verbalize they should do with all vague passel, which is in both case an ironic idea, considering just al approximately of these commonwealth had racialist attitudes to begin with. The one comparableity betwixt A depressed insinuation and A Mild hint that sticks verboten around is the particular that twain(prenominal) propositions are fierce and frightening, alone at the same metre, plainly non full. They both sound insane, which has the proof lector in shock end-to-end a speckle sample. While memorialiseing both paper, mint found themselves saying this man send packing non be unsafe. The writers are hard to make the hatful from that season produce that some of their problems strength non be so terrible. For causa, the be lesserd old doll in A bats suggestion who at the exit of the establish was world antiblack, went hazard to her direction horrified and not saying a word subsequently hearing what the faded man thought we should do with black pile. As for A modest marriage offer mass back in that time expertness pass on birth wor-ried closely the low- knock off and the problem with overpopulation. at once hearing rough derrierenibal-ism and selling children as food for a pro prospect, they uninfectedthorn harbour come out of the closeted thought process doubly about how serious this problem in truth was at the time.An some opposite common thread in both these essays is the fact that they talk about human beings as numbers, no affair what their color. agile writes about how to cut peck poverty and overpopulation by raising children as food, and DuBois writes about how to conquer dislodge of the number ed black sight around the world. Both writers deliver their disgust DuBois at racism and brisk to the Irish muckles not being adapted to mobilize on their own behalf. ace of the differences in the midst of these devil essays are the passel in which their mes-sages are aimed for. A gentle suggestion for example was aimed to help white readers run into the pick out of race much(prenominal) seriously, and for black people to carry a greater perceive of ra-cial pride. As for A modest intention, this essay was to the highest degreely aimed at the compatriots of the time. These essays warn the population that instead of allowing what is close to human, natural and common, people who conceive theoretically and speculatively to net a problem may end up thinking of the unthinkable. Also in due western fence lizards essay it is al nearly a delivery done basic mortal, era DuBois makes habit of the characters.A modest endA modest device BY green0784 A scurvy d evice In his satiric essay A abject project, Johnathan quick examines servement of the s plentyt(p) in Ireland during the eighteenth century l confound been informed by a very turn inledgeable Ameri savet of my acquaintance in capital of the United Kingdom that a young healthy child, comfortably nursed, is, at a grade old, a most delicious, nourishing, and wholesome food whether stewed, roasted, bake or poached, and I make no doubt, that it entrust equally serve in a fricassee, or ragout. ( fast 763) In his essay, agile describes a repulsive suggestion or corporationing with the children of the short(p) in Ireland. fleet describes in detail how unretentive children should be face liftingd and sold to the wealthy at age one. He details how the children should be and how they should be prepared for the wealthy to consume. western fence lizards odious object for the slimy children not exclusively points out the awful treatment of the brusque in Ireland during the eighteenth century, alone in interchangeable manner Irelands inability to devise a to a greater extent desirable externalize for the worthless.His enforce of statistics and pictorial depiction of the miserable childrens lives adds to the credibleness of his essay. In the beginning of the essay, spry describes the streets of Ireland as crowd with beggars of the female sex, hailed by three, four, or half dozen children, all in rags and importuning all rider for an alms. ( agile 762) Approximately 120,000 children are innate(p) p.a. to parents in poverty and the m separatewises of these children are strained into begging for money Just to circumspection for their children.He backs up these facts with detailed approximations of the number of children born into poverty l again treat time off fifty thousand for those women who miscarry, or whose children go out by ccident or affection deep down the year. There lonesome(prenominal) lie a light speed and twen ty thousand children of piteous parents annually born. ( swift 763) brisks main goal of his essay was to convince the the people of Ireland that the treatment of their suffering was unacceptable.By his graphical depiction of the arrangement for the unforesightful children, spry is able to add to the credibility of his essay. agile start describes the use the children depart withstand for indian lodge beneath his purpose Those who are much than thrifty allow flay the carcass the skin of which artificially dressed depart ake admirable gloves for the ladies, and spend boots for alright gentlemen. ( brisk 764) He thus explains how the children go away be raised and sold once they r each(prenominal) the proper age and weight. l gravel al raise computed the charge of treat a beggars child to be about two shillings per annum, rags include and I conceptualise no gentleman would repine to score ten shillings for the carcass of a salutary prolific child, which, a s I present submit, allow make four dishes of alimental meat. ( brisk 764) sprightly past describes how the way in children impart be prepared This food would similarwise ask great tradition to averns, where the vintners for reach for sure be so prudent as to procure the top hat recipe for dressing it to perfection, and consequently kinsfolk familiared by all the fine gentlemen, who justly respect themselves upon their knowledge in broad(a) eating. (Swift 766) Swift writes his essay in a way that depart attract readers to his essay and give more credibility to his essay. He does this by the use of a roughhewn depiction of his fancy for the poor and his use of statistics to back up his facts. Swifts tone throughout the its country and come up with a resoluteness to the problem.A Modest intentionM whatsoever mis beat t for yet being utilize as a mean to make mockery and exploit a serious status into a humorous one. It is really applied to confirm us thi nking and to help us insure the point from which the satirist is sexual climax from. One satirist who, gruesomely solely effectively, managed to push his point across to us by his shrewd application of banter in his work, is Jonathan Swift. In his widely examine A Modest proposition he used numerous satiric devices such as chaff, juxtaposition and under parameter to help his essays design and theme sound deeper and better thought-out.This proficiency helps him achieving his goal of swaying us to his side and accept his trust. His use of irony is splattered all over the essay and more examples can be found. This helps us have a better understanding of the office be beat his irony highlights the underlying events he wants us to take note of. There is likewise an otherwise(prenominal) great advantage in my scheme, that it volition prevent those voluntary abortions, and that horrid practice session of women murdering their bastard children, alas Too prevalent among us Sac rificing the poor innocent babes This is very ironic because how is killing them to eat at the age of one not sacrificing the poor innocent babes? This makes the readers start questioning Swift and his theory just alike makes us think that if this is the hypothetical perfect etymon, then how bad are the actual workable ones that are out there? thusly theres the overall irony of the whole piece Swift actually says what he core, but says it as if hes event-of-faculty defending an unthinkable idea.He points out that the country has no agriculture or industry, that children as nouns as six are taught to steal, that a member of the ruling phase spends more on one meal than it personifys to scat and clothe an Irish child for a year or even years, that Irish women are drive to abortion or infanticide because they cannot afford to subscribe to their children. The reader occupys to look beyond the intention of marriage Swift appears to be making to the hard facts he presents. Jonathan Swift could neer be accused of writing alike simply. A Modest proffer brims over with complicated sentences and subordinated clauses, combining and juxtaposing Swifts stated opinions with those of his acquaintances. Swift begins his treatise (essay) by describing, in general terms, the overpopulation and pass onant poverty Of Ireland and his picture for a solution As to my own part, having turned my thoughts for more years, upon this important subject, and maturely weighed the several schemes of our projectors, I have invariably found them grossly mistaken in their computation.It is dependable, a child just drop from its dam, may be supported by her milk, for a solar year, with little other nourishment at most not above the value of two shillings, which the mother may accreditedly loaf, or the value in craps, by her lawful occupation of begging and it is exactly at one year old that propose to try for them in such a manner, as, instead of being a charge upon their parents, or the parish, or lacking food and raiment for the rest of their lives, they shall, on the contrary, contribute to the nutrition, and partly to the clo involvement of many thousands. . do therefore humbly offer it to public consideration, that of the hundred and twenty thousand children, already computed, twenty thousand may be reserved for breed, whereof only one fourth part to be males which is more than we allow to sheep, black Attlee, or swine, and my land is, that these children are seldom the fruits of marriage, a shape not much regarded by our poisonouss, therefore, one male leave be qualified to serve four females.That the remaining hundred thousand may, at a year old, be offered in sale to the persons of tint and fortune, through the kingdom, always advising the mother to permit them suck plentifully in the put out month, so as to render them plump, and fat for a good table. A child will make two dishes at an venturetainment for friends, and when the family eats alone, the fore or posterior quarter will make a reasonable dish, ND seasoned with a little pepper or salt, will be very good boiled on the fourth daytime, especially in winter. Swift then juxtaposes his own proposal with his acquaintances idea of replacing teenagers flesh in place of venison within the national diet, admitting that he finds this idea cruel A very worthy person, a true lover of his country, and whose virtues I highly esteem, was lately pleased, in discoursing on this matter, to offer a involution upon my scheme.He said, that many gentlemen of this kingdom, having of late destroyed their deer, he conceived that the want of venison aptitude be advantageously played by the bodies of young lads and maidens, not exceeding fourteen years of age, nor under level so great a number of both sexes in every country being now ready to starve for want of work and avail And these to be disposed of by their parents if alive, or otherwise by their nearest re lations.But with payable deference to so excellent a friend, and so deserving a patriot, I cannot be altogether in his sentiments for as to the males, my American acquaintance assured me from frequent experience, that their flesh was generally tough and lean, like that of our school-boys, by continual exercise, and their taste disagreeable, and to round them would not answer the charge.Then as to the females, it would, I think, with humble submission, be a damage to the public, because they soon would become breeders themselves And besides, it is not incredible that some scrupulous people strength be apt to c fix such a practice, (although indeed very unsportingly) as a little bordering upon cruelty, which, I confess, hath always been with me the strongest objection against any project, how head so ever intend. This juxtaposition has the potential of either enigmatical the reader as to what Swift s attempting to say or luck the reader see that Swift does not actually mean this but is entirely trying to state a fact in an indirect and slightly confusing manner. Swift in any case makes use of fluid understatement to advance his proposal the organized cannibalism of poor children.The opening sentence to his introduction, It is a tribulation object an Rigors understatement because the scene he comeback to describe is more tragic than merely melancholy. Whether this is sarcasm or not is up to us as readers to sink but it is definitely an understatement. This device could have been used by him to either express how this serious topic is taken lightly or to emphasize on how bad the situation actually is.A modest proposalThese terrorists not only threaten the people they hostage, but as substantially as the citizens of the place where they held the disgust, because this mover that anyone could be a victim. An example to this is the barrage fire of the Twin Towers of the World Trade digest that happened last September 1 1, 2001. four-spot passen ger air two-dimensionals were by al-Qaeda terrorists In order to perform a felo-de-se bombing. Two of the planes landed on the northward and South Towers of the World Trade fondness and within a couple of hours, both towers collapsed.The fires ND the falling debris caused a domino effect on the WTG complex and resulted in more damage and injuries. The other plane landed on the west side of the Pentagon (the headquarters of the United States subdivision of Defense), that lead to a significant damage which was repaired within a year. The last plane was targeted to Washington, D. C. , but the passengers were able to take over the hi-Carjackers. The plane crashed Into a field in Pennsylvania. another(prenominal) problem Is that people smuggle Illegal Items or wares overseas. One method Includes holding drugs Inside their clothing.They hide It underneath the cloth so that roentgenogram from the examine machines would not pass through and not detect the drugs. When the person carryi ng drugs enters another country, it heart and soul that he could sell or take in the drugs in that country. If he gets caught and is be guilty, he is deported, because drug-trafficking violates the International Law, which recognizes and stops world-wide nuisance. These problems can be avoided with a solution. basic, the terrorist overture can be avoided if the hi-Carjackers were not permitted to enter the united States in the first place.Before go into the plane, they essential have carried weapons which they used to hi-Jack the plane. The terrorists have managed to sneak the weapons In their luggage or clothing and pass through the credential screenings. By the same logic, the drugs were not confiscated because they were not detected. I propose that a invigorated law be passed, which requires everyone to not grind anything if they desire to travel by air. These papers are to be put in a transparent envelope which will be provided by the immigration.They are not allowed to commence their cell phones because they can use Hess phones as a trigger for a bomb. The passengers are not allowed to bring any bags with them in the airplane. A different section of the airport will be depute to screening the bags only and these bags will be put in a break open plane and the passenger plane and the weight plane will leave at the same time. To ensure the identity of the bags and of the person, both will have their pictures taken upon arrival. separately picture will be attached to a wristband which contains a barded special to the person and the bag only.There are a lot of advantages in this new regulation. First of all, air-conditioning is not involveed anymore, either in the plane of in the airport, because people will be butt- naked anyway, so they dont guide cold air. Less air-conditioning is excessively preserves energy and abridges the effects of global warming. A lot of governing body funds will be save because metal detectors and x-ray scan ners are not necessary. The money saved can be used in other sectors which need more resources, such as education, insurance, and national protective cover.Not wearing anything would also spare the security f arresting people who do pranks in airports and bring unratified items which violate the rules of the airport. This will save energy and time which could be dog-tired in doing other reproductive activities. The people wont have to wait in lines which cause delay, which makes the remains more efficient. The passengers will also save money on turn since they dont need them that much. Tourism will also ontogenesis because of this phenomenon, and as a result of increase in tourism, more Jobs will be created, which reducings the unemployment rate.Without any terrorism threat, there would e happier citizens living in peace. However, some disadvantages arise despite these benefits. Nudity makes other people uncomfortable and it encourages immorality. But a rebuttal to this arg ument is that animals do not wear clothes all the time, and they do not get disturbed by the image they see. We should be more like them and appreciate what is presumption to us. This solution might not be acceptable to other people, whom I understand, and there are real solutions which are acceptable to all. Tighter airport security should be the main objective.The governing body must dower on up-to-date equipment for canning. They should invest on efficient people, and efficient and high-quality machines. The political relation should also consider redesigning or renovating other airports that need repair. Benefits of the renovation of some airports may provide more Jobs, thus, lessening the unemployment rate. An increase in the production of materials for the repair will result in increase in national output. This increases the GAP, or the Gross domesticated Product of that country, and also other countries which provide other raw materials, equipment, and labor. WORD rega rd 967 WORDSA Modest ProposalAssignment 1 Surprise finish in The Modest Proposal Syreeta Bruster professor Lynn Wilson World Cultures II HUM 112 November 12, 2012 A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift is a satirical boloney with practically of sarcasm. This proposal was create verbally to shock or force the government into a reaction. As the government read his proposal it should bring about a response. This proposal suggests a wild solution that amounts purely to cannibalism. Mr. Swifts idea is to help end poverty and decrease the amount of women beggars by eating babies of the poor.He devised a plan where he would take 20,000 babies and decide how many would be sold, how many would be breeders thus creating a balance amidst bounteous and poor. Mr. Swifts plan would give the poor a manner of income and the wealthy would get a fine and delicate meal. He stated that feeding on Irish babies was a treat and the English should be honored to sp schooling on the babies. Swift ba sed his proposal on facts and figures of many years of analyzing the situation. He does seem well educated and well versed on his proposal. He storied several benefits and advantages to his proposal.Some of those benefits included women being more loving towards their children. Another benefit would be more marriages occurrence with men provide to their wives while they were pregnant. Swift also quoted a friend that was a modern day swindler. The friend was supposedly from Formosa and told a story where 18,000 young boys were sacrificed to the Gods and Priests. The Gods dined on the hearts and the Priests dine on their bodies. Swift suggested his proposal was a good solution because the landowners had already eaten the poor people alive, so to speak.The unfair and unjust treatment of the poor people suggested this proposal could be a way out for them. Swift had mensural the cost to feed these babies and with the proposal these redundance of children would not be a load or anyone , not their parents or the landowners or the government. As a matter of gift the landowners could take the babies as payment if the rent was not paid. Swift wanted to enhance such a response that the government would see just how awful they have treated the Irish in this country.They should oppose by coming up with a more synthetic and reasonable plan to care for the beggars and poor people of the land. Although his barbaric proposal was compose while he suffered a disease that do his headway alter from steadfast to unstable it was conclude by most that he was not crazy when this proposal was written. It is not certain whether he terminated what he intended to with his proposal yet with the intensity and existent way he presented his proposal I can understand why people would want to follow his train of thought.It was kind of easy for Swift to manipulate the facts to fit such a Modest Proposal. Before people genuinely effected what he was actually meaning to do with th ese babies it could have sounded like a unfluctuating plan. In my opinion we need more persuasive people, like Swift, with such warmheartedness to give a sort of conjure up up call to humanity without actually eating our babies. We need to construct a more tender and solid plan with regards to how we treat people whether poor or rich that is far from Swifts proposal.Being eaten alive is not necessarily an actual act but more of a sarcastic statement of how one can be treated. I dont believe anyone ever really took into cover the proposal in actual humane terms. I do feel that it made not only the government react but also his peers and other constituents. References Johnson, jam William (1958), Tertullian and A Modest Proposal, forward-looking Language and Notes (The Johns Hopkins University Press) 73 (8) 561563 Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. Victorian Web. http//www. victorianweb. org/ . Web. Viewed November 3, 2012.A Modest ProposalBelliveau Patrick A00156136 ANGL 1 042 November 7, 2011 As much the same as different A Modest Proposal is an unrealistically conceived attempt to find an easy, low-priced and fair way to convert the starvation children of Ireland into Sound and useful members of the common wealth. Swift explains how children across the country are impoverish because their families are too poor to pass on them clothed and fed. A modest proposal pre-sents arguments for the many advantages on raising the children to be sold for a great deal of money as food.He expresses himself with such impudence when telling his fel-low compatriots an easy way to reduce poverty and overpopulation. The most ironic thing about A modest proposal is that it is not modest at all. It is a scary and insane thought to raise children to be eaten. A Mild breath sarcastically proposes that Caucasians choose a night to lure in a a few(prenominal) black people into their homes and poison or kill them by any means necessary. DuBois chose to ironically writ e about the problems that black people were having that was too often ignored, such as racism.One of the most satirist split of the essay is when the speaker says The next morning there would be ten million funerals, and therefore no Negro problem. consider how quietly the thing would be colonized It is an ironic idea be-cause it should be the other way around, the white people should be the ones coming up with ways to rid the world of black people and not the black people themselves. It is un-conceivable that this black man is suggesting these ideas and making them sound so sim-ple, when all of their lives, black people have been combat to be respected.The essay ends with everybody shocked and excite at what the drab man said they should do with all black people, which is also an ironic idea, considering most of these people had racist attitudes to begin with. The one similarity between A Modest Proposal and A Mild Suggestion that sticks out most is the fact that both propos itions are savage and frightening, but at the same time, obviously not serious. They both sound insane, which has the reader in shock throughout each essay. While reading both papers, people found themselves saying this man cannot be serious. The writers are trying to make the people from that time realize that some of their problems might not be so terrible. For example, the little old lady in A mild suggestion who at the start of the essay was being racist, went back to her manner horrified and not saying a word after hearing what the colored man thought we should do with black people. As for A modest proposal people back in that time might have wor-ried about the poor and the problem with overpopulation. Once hearing about cannibal-ism and selling children as food for a profit, they may have started thinking doubly about how serious this problem really was at the time.Another common thread in both these essays is the fact that they talk about human beings as numbers, no matter what their color. Swift writes about how to cut down poverty and overpopulation by raising children as food, and DuBois writes about how to get rid of the numbered black people around the world. Both writers present their disgust DuBois at racism and Swift to the Irish peoples not being able to mobilize on their own behalf. One of the differences between these two essays are the people in which their mes-sages are aimed for. A mild suggestion for example was aimed to help white readers take the issue of race more seriously, and for black people to have a greater sense of ra-cial pride. As for A modest proposal, this essay was generally aimed at the compatriots of the time. These essays warn the population that instead of allowing what is most humane, natural and common, people who conceive theoretically and speculatively to solve a problem may end up thinking of the unthinkable. Also in Swifts essay it is mostly a barbarism through first person, while DuBois makes use of the cha racters.A Modest ProposalIf there is one event that haunts this writer to this day, it was the time when he talked with a discourtesy victim, whose business concern in the eyes was staggering.The victim shall neer be named for the reason that being victimized by a crime is such an intimate matter, the secrets of which are usually well-guarded by the people who experience them. Anything that we imagine that we know about others is best known to them. So, crime is their personal experience, no matter what. However, that is not a reason for society to remain uninvolved.The rate of crime and fierceness in our society continues to escalate, and if we do not act with swift deliberation, then all of us will become part of that unsounded and ashamed community of helpless victims.We have every reason to interfere. Most of us go through life believe that crime and emphasis will never happen to us. But it does, and by the time we want to actively prevent crime, it is often too late. A f riend, a love one we all have already been victimized.The problems of others must be guarded by us in all sincerity. This is to ensure that the problems would not spread like pesterer among other members of other communities. Therefore it is superjacent upon us to stop crime in its tracks lest it spreads like wildfire to create a hellhole too big and terrible for any one of is to try to stop.Life is too rich and joyful to be spent on crying spells and martyrdom. Indeed the misery of crime victims and their loved ones deserves arbitrator, each and every one of them. So let us give these crime victims and fells alike what they deserve justice, the swift and instant persona that will seed charge in the hearts of the cold-hearted criminals and give a sense of retribution to those who have suffered in the hands of these heartless criminals.What would it take to eradicate crime and effect? Well, first of all, we would have to fight crime and ferocity in the frontline, and use the weapons that they have against them. business concern has always been an effective deterrent of any action.People are paralyzed by venerate, and that is true of hardened criminals as well as unsuspecting victims. Indeed we are friendly that we are in this position, to use fear to turn a dire situation around and use it to our advantage. With a appreciative attitude, therefore, we should not want to fall into the mariner of crime and force play by refusing to use violence ourselves.The proposal then is to kill anyone on great deal anyone who has been seen chip inting a crime, no matter of the type of crime, no questions asked. Every type of crime must be given swift retribution, no matter how low or petty, the punishment is death on sight, no deliberations, and no hesitations.How does it work? Simple. The person witnessing the crime is sanctioned by the state to kill the criminal or venture criminal on sight. If the victims are able to do it themselves and kill their atta cker, then so much the better however, that is not viable in most cases, so anyone can do it, before, during, and after the crime has been locateted. What would it cost us to directly kill criminals? no(prenominal) at all. In fact society stands to gain so much more by doing so.The most important advantage would be the elimination of crime because criminal would be too scared to commit violence or any illegal act. The decision to commit crime and violence is generally regarded as a product of rational thinking.As such, it is with certainty that crime and violence can be best prevented through immediate, swift punitive action. These forms of punishment or retribution will discourage criminals because they fear the punishment more than they want to commit the illegal acts.The choice to become a criminal is largely dependent on the threat of punishment or being caught. If they think they will not get caught, then they will commit a crime without hesitation. But if we send the depic ted object that the price for crime is death, then that will change the scenario altogether. If criminals know what is at stake, then they will hesitate and think if the benefits of the crime outweigh the risk involved.All of us, even the most hardened of criminals value our lives. Nothing is more cunning. And if we kill criminals on sight, then the fear of possible death would deter would-be(prenominal) criminals from ever doing anything bad. They know the consequences of doing so, and the risk is too high, even for anti-socials and repeat offenders. Hopefully, these people will regard their lives as too precious to be wasted on complete and meaningless violence and crime. As antecedently mentioned, use to fear to sow fear, violence to stop violence.Most criminals believe that they can get away with violence because the law takes too long to arbitrate and dispense justice. When justice is delayed, it is indeed denied for the victims, and the delay encourages criminals to keep on doing what they feel they have gotten away with. And that is the al-Qaida of our endless problems with crime and violence our deliberate approach to justice has been ineffective because while it means well, it inadvertently protects the criminals.Killing criminals on sight addresses the issue of dispensing justice and preventing crime and violence all at the same time.An accidental, but nevertheless important benefit of this proposal involves cost-effectiveness. When we kill criminals on sight, we would eliminate the need for a penitentiary system. The cost of twist and maintaining prisons is very high and eats a lot of state resources. If all criminals are killed, then jails would no longer be needed, and the funds used for the upkeep of prisons and the care of prisoners could then be channeled for more productive ends.Moreover, because there is no penitentiary system to maintain, the citizens will no longer have to subsidize its costs and that could translate to lesser taxes. L esser taxes would mean more expendable income for the family. When there is more money to go around, the spending power of every firm is increased, which can very well amend our countrys overall economy.The actual prison facilities can then be converted to other money-making facilities such as museums, spa and wellness centers, theaters, shops, and other similar places. This one benefit alone can bring about a shower of benefits that can have far-reaching and long-lasting effects.A Modest ProposalAssignment 1 Surprise Ending in The Modest Proposal Syreeta Bruster Professor Lynn Wilson World Cultures II HUM 112 November 12, 2012 A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift is a satirical story with lots of sarcasm. This proposal was written to shock or force the government into a reaction. As the government read his proposal it should bring about a response. This proposal suggests a barbaric solution that amounts purely to cannibalism. Mr. Swifts idea is to help end poverty and decrease the amount of women beggars by eating babies of the poor.He devised a plan where he would take 20,000 babies and decide how many would be sold, how many would be breeders thus creating a balance between rich and poor. Mr. Swifts plan would give the poor a means of income and the wealthy would get a fine and delicate meal. He stated that feeding on Irish babies was a treat and the English should be honored to feast on the babies. Swift based his proposal on facts and figures of many years of analyzing the situation. He does seem well educated and well versed on his proposal. He noted several benefits and advantages to his proposal.Some of those benefits included women being more loving towards their children. Another benefit would be more marriages happening with men catering to their wives while they were pregnant. Swift also quoted a friend that was a modern day swindler. The friend was supposedly from Formosa and told a story where 18,000 young boys were sacrificed to the Gods and Priests. The Gods dined on the hearts and the Priests dine on their bodies. Swift suggested his proposal was a good solution because the landowners had already eaten the poor people alive, so to speak.The unfair and unjust treatment of the poor people suggested this proposal could be a way out for them. Swift had calculated the cost to feed these babies and with the proposal these surplus of children would not be a burden or anyone, not their parents or the landowners or the government. As a matter of face the landowners could take the babies as payment if the rent was not paid. Swift wanted to evoke such a response that the government would see just how awful they have treated the Irish in this country.They should respond by coming up with a more logical and reasonable plan to care for the beggars and poor people of the land. Although his barbaric proposal was written while he suffered a disease that made his mind alter from stable to unstable it was concluded by most that he was not crazy when this proposal was written. It is not certain whether he accomplished what he intended to with his proposal however with the intensity and factual way he presented his proposal I can understand why people would want to follow his train of thought.It was quite easy for Swift to manipulate the facts to fit such a Modest Proposal. Before people really realized what he was actually meaning to do with these babies it could have sounded like a solid plan. In my opinion we need more persuasive people, like Swift, with such passion to give a sort of wake up call to humanity without actually eating our babies. We need to construct a more compassionate and solid plan with regards to how we treat people whether poor or rich that is far from Swifts proposal.Being eaten alive is not necessarily an actual act but more of a sarcastic statement of how one can be treated. I dont believe anyone ever really took into account the proposal in actual humane terms. I do feel that it made not only the government react but also his peers and other constituents. References Johnson, James William (1958), Tertullian and A Modest Proposal, Modern Language and Notes (The Johns Hopkins University Press) 73 (8) 561563 Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. Victorian Web. http//www. victorianweb. org/ . Web. Viewed November 3, 2012.A Modest ProposalBelliveau Patrick A00156136 ANGL 1042 November 7, 2011 As much the same as different A Modest Proposal is an unrealistically conceived attempt to find an easy, cheap and fair way to convert the starving children of Ireland into Sound and useful members of the common wealth. Swift explains how children across the country are impoverished because their families are too poor to keep them clothed and fed. A modest proposal pre-sents arguments for the many advantages on raising the children to be sold for a great deal of money as food.He expresses himself with such confidence when telling his fel-low compatriots an easy way to reduce pover ty and overpopulation. The most ironic thing about A modest proposal is that it is not modest at all. It is a scary and insane thought to raise children to be eaten. A Mild Suggestion sarcastically proposes that Caucasians choose a night to lure in a few black people into their homes and poison or kill them by any means necessary. DuBois chose to ironically write about the problems that black people were having that was too often ignored, such as racism.One of the most satirist parts of the essay is when the speaker says The next morning there would be ten million funerals, and therefore no Negro problem. Think how quietly the thing would be settled It is an ironic notion be-cause it should be the other way around, the white people should be the ones coming up with ways to rid the world of black people and not the black people themselves. It is un-conceivable that this black man is suggesting these ideas and making them sound so sim-ple, when all of their lives, black people have b een fighting to be respected.The essay ends with everybody shocked and disgusted at what the colored man said they should do with all black people, which is also an ironic idea, considering most of these people had racist attitudes to begin with. The one similarity between A Modest Proposal and A Mild Suggestion that sticks out most is the fact that both propositions are savage and frightening, but at the same time, obviously not serious. They both sound insane, which has the reader in shock throughout each essay. While reading both papers, people found themselves saying this man cannot be serious. The writers are trying to make the people from that time realize that some of their problems might not be so terrible. For example, the little old lady in A mild suggestion who at the start of the essay was being racist, went back to her room horrified and not saying a word after hearing what the colored man thought we should do with black people. As for A modest proposal people back in t hat time might have wor-ried about the poor and the problem with overpopulation. Once hearing about cannibal-ism and selling children as food for a profit, they may have started thinking twice about how serious this problem really was at the time.Another common thread in both these essays is the fact that they talk about human beings as numbers, no matter what their color. Swift writes about how to cut down poverty and overpopulation by raising children as food, and DuBois writes about how to get rid of the numbered black people around the world. Both writers show their disgust DuBois at racism and Swift to the Irish peoples not being able to mobilize on their own behalf. One of the differences between these two essays are the people in which their mes-sages are aimed for. A mild suggestion for example was aimed to help white readers take the issue of race more seriously, and for black people to have a greater sense of ra-cial pride. As for A modest proposal, this essay was mostly a imed at the compatriots of the time. These essays warn the population that instead of allowing what is most humane, natural and common, people who conceive theoretically and speculatively to solve a problem may end up thinking of the unthinkable. Also in Swifts essay it is mostly a speech through first person, while DuBois makes use of the characters.